If Only Selig Had the Guts
Once again, Major League Baseball Commissioner Bud Selig has swung and missed. His announcement that George Mitchell has been hired to lead an investigation on past steroid use in the sport is yet another feeble attempt at redemption. Unfortunately, in the long run this investigation will prove pointless. It will prove to only deflect blame and line up scapegoats. It will not solve the problem. It will not clear the air. What Selig and his advisors fail to realize is that the damage has been done. And no amount of asterisks or apologies will rectify the image of the “steroid era” in baseball.
What MLB needs is leadership at the top. A leader who can move the sport forward instead of forcing it backward. A leader who understands that there are far more guilty parties in this case than anyone is willing to admit.
Since Selig won’t do what needs to be done, I will do it for him. He could call one press conference, read one statement, and this entire situation would be over. Baseball could move forward and never look back. What Selig needs to do is step to the podium and say this.....
“I have called this press conference today to inform you that Major League Baseball has cancelled the investigation by George Mitchell into the steroid scandal. Furthermore, we have decided to call off all investigations of players’ past indiscretions. While many may view this announcement as taking the easy way out, we have concluded that it is, in fact, the only way out.
First of all, if baseball were to continue this investigation, we would need to start the snooping in the league offices. We would need to start it in my office, and in the offices of the commissioners and officials who came before me. Clearly, baseball leadership allowed a terrible problem to fester for years without blinking an eye. Despite evidence of rampant abuse of performance-enhancing drugs, most baseball executives failed to make any decisive moves until the problem raged so far into the public eye that we had no choice but to act. What has followed has been a wild disgrace of blame-shifting and finger-pointing. Everyone is at fault.
Secondly, after much research, we have determined that any investigation will prove to be unfair, as we have never quite been able to clearly identify what constitutes a "performance-enhancing" drug. We do not know exactly when the problem started. We are not completely sure where to start, or who to investigate. Obviously, there have been some very highly publicized incidents involving high-profile players. But we are not interested in lynch mobs or witch hunts. If we are to do this, we are to do this uniformly, fairly, and without regard to the stature of the person being investigated. Unfortunately, it is simply too unrealistic to proceed with this process under those parameters. Sadly, we must face the fact that we dropped the ball so badly on this subject, that there is no way to investigate the issue while maintaining the integrity that it deserves.
Many people want to know what we are going to do about the record books. The answer is simple: NOTHING. As I said earlier, there is no discernable way to investigate all allegations fully; therefore there is no way to address the record books across the board. There will be no asterisks; there will be no erasers. Baseball has faced similar situations in the past. All elements and eras have not always been created equally. We have not erased records set in the first half of the 20th century even though African-American and Latin players were not allowed to participate. How can we notate a record set by a batter when we aren’t sure whether or not the pitcher he faced was also cheating? How do we determine team records if their players were cheating? Do we erase World Series champions? Do we take away rings? Unless we discover a way to definitively expose all methods of cheating in the past, we will not be able to address the record books. The books will remain the same. The only asterisks that will exist will be in the hearts and minds of the fans, which is really the only place it matters.
We have concluded that the past will forever be left in the past. Our focus now turns to the future. Baseball has survived gambling scandals, work stoppages, and price increases. At each juncture, the game has proven to be bigger than those who participate in it. It has survived. It will always survive. From this point forward, all we can do is acknowledge our colossal mistakes of the past, and make every effort to avoid this situation in the future. Our testing policies will be very strict. We will hire the best people to help baseball stay on pace with science, and stay ahead of the cheaters. We will clearly define what cheating means, and we will clearly define how to punish those who are caught. If there are still players throughout the league who may be under suspicion, the only court they will deal with is the court of public opinion.
Today marks the first day of the rest of Major League Baseball’s life. Fans can do what they please with the memories and records of the past, and take solace in the fact that we have taken a strong stand to forever rid baseball of those looking for an unfair advantage.
Baseball is the American game. And Americans are smart. Do we really need an official investigation to let us know that cheaters were prospering? The answer is clear, and so is the solution. Look in the mirror, take your share of the blame, and move on. That’s what we’re doing today.”
